Posted by
Anthony Rizzuto on Friday, November 07, 2008 3:02:31 AM
So, what really happened on November 4th? Quite a few things actually. All of them spelled disaster for the Republican party. For the moment, let's leave out the presidents lack of popularity, everyone knows that took it's toll. To paraphrase William Shakespeare, "The fault dear John, lies not in the stars, but in ourselves."
First, a moderate was nominated as our standard bearer not a true conservative. This caused the following to occur, a decrease in Republican turnout (1.2 percent did not show up at the polls). Of the ones that did show up, 21% voted for the opposition party, some on the basis that "If we're going to elect a Democrat anyway, we might as well vote for the real thing".
Next, McCain and the party lacked a clear cohesive message "I will put an end to earmarks" doesn't translate. That's inside speak. Voters 18 to 24 probably thought he intended to outlaw piercings. In the midst of what is arguably the worst economy in a generation, McCain needed to offer specific proposals to deal with it. Threatening to “out” those guilty of "pork barrel" spending ( more inside speak) means what to the guy who just lost his job and is facing foreclosure? Touting that "we will win the war" and “our troops will return with dignity“ again means what to those who can't put food on their tables and either stopped caring about the war or never supported it to begin with? In short, the message he did have, appealed to neither conservatives, or moderates.
Third, he tried to put a Band-Aid on a gaping wound by choosing Sara Palin as his running mate. Please note, I am in no way knocking Mrs. Palin, but her selection only served to highlight the conservative credentials Senator McCain lacked. In our party, the conservative needs to be on the top, not the bottom of the ticket.
Fourth, our loss to some extent was cyclical. After eight years of being in the wilderness, Democrats were simply hungrier for a win than we were and the increase in their turnout (2.6 %) reflected that.
With a Republican base that felt alienated and uninspired, going up against a group that was rabid to recapture the oval office, who also had a candidate that articulated a clear, albeit, simple message, we were doomed from the time McCain captured the nomination.
Finally, because McCain opted to use public rather than private financing, he was fighting with one hand tied behind his back. His lack of funds kept him from campaigning effectively during the six weeks the Democrats were still fighting to pick their nominee.
Well, there you have it, the anatomy of how to lose an election. Time to get back to basics and rebuild from the ground up, the way we did between 1976 and 1980.